Conducting observational research deakin university. On the contrary, participant observation is a complex method that has many components. Accordingly, as noted by tedlock, the distinction between participant observation and observant participation is one that establishes a representational transformation 11. Spradley 1980 provides five different types of participant.
The basic prerriise guiding our investigation is the belief that the role of the participant observer is subject to two types of social force present in the setting, one stemming from predetermined environmental factors, and a second created through social in. Pdf from participant observation to the observation of. The email from thom didato this afternoon inspired me to pull the plug on this for now. Nice concise chapters with lots of information, little fluff and truthfully enjoyable to read. This article is based on the experience of the author while carrying out his doctoral thesis, a yearlong participant observation among saipem. This paper provides a look at various definitions of participant observation, the history of its use, the purposes for which it is used, the stances of the. Ethnopoetics is a method of recording text versions of oral poetry or narrative performances i. Although these continue until the end of the field project, as indicted by the broken line, the emphasis shifts first to focused observations and later to selective observations. As a qualitative method, ethnography has been walking through. Dec 15, 2016 participant observation has long been an important social inquiry tool in sociological investigation of the social world and in applied sociology. While participant observation aimed to uncover the world of female gamblers with firsthand exploration of naturalistic gambling settings, indepth interviewing intended to reveal the meanings of female gambling by attending to. Unstructured non participant observation is used in qualitative research, while structured observation is used in both quantitative and qualitative depending on the aim of the study. There have been changes recently to the use of participant observation as a data collection strategy in qualitative research.
These moments overlap and simultaneously operate in the pres ent. As a data gathering technique, observation is generally categorized as either participant observation, in which the researchers are involved in the activity being observed, or nonparticipant. As a data gathering technique, observation is generally categorized as either participant observation, in which the researchers are involved in the activity being observed, or non participant. Participant observation was created during the late 19th century as an eth nographic field method for the study of. Ethnographers were expected to live in a society for an extended period of time. If you continue browsing the site, you agree to the use of cookies on this website. Beginning in the 1970s there has been a shift in cultural anthropological methodology from participant observation toward the observation of participation. Ethnographic fieldwork, carried out according to the method of longterm participant observation, is what defines social anthropology. From participant observation to the observation of participation. The email from thom didato this afternoon inspired me to. The emergence of narrative ethnography1 barbara tedlock department of anthropology, state university of new york at buffalo, buffalo, ny 14261 beginning in the 1970s there has been a shift in cultural anthropological methodology.
During participant observation ethnographers attempt to be both emotionally engaged participants and coolly dispassionate observers of the lives of others. Participant observation to research education revisesociology. Participant observation involves the observer being a member of the setting in which they are collecting data there are quite a few variations of this definition observation is normally associated with an ethnographic methodology more later but can be used as part of other research designs. Barbara and dennis tedlock interviewed february 1112 2005 in the weaving workshop of angel xiloj, momostenango, guatemala barbara tedlock is an anthropologist and ethnographer whose work has focused on the zuni of the american southwest and the maya of highland guatemala. The goal of participant observation is no longer solely to describe cultural practices tedlock, 2000. As an anthro major who has done a lot in the discipline, but never had an explicit text that put all the info and strategies on participant observation in one place before, i love this book. In north america, qualitative research operates in a complex historical field that crosscuts at least eight historical moments. Settings and procedure based on an initial scoping exercise examining all the possible types of places and environments that house fruit machines, and guidance from preliminary informants, four key types of setting were selected for observation in our research. Participant observation has been used by researchers in recent years to collect data about. More commonly, however, it is viewed positivistically as useful during the preliminary stages of scientific inquiry for exploration and description lazarsfeld, 1972.
One of the first things that a researcher or individual must do after deciding to conduct participant observations to gather data is decide what kind of participant observer he or she will be. Barbara tedlock 1991 observed a shift in late 20thcentury ethnographic writing from participant observation to what she termed the. Tedlock, barbara 1991 from participant observation to the observation of participation. Tracing a home for praxisoriented ethnography sage journals. Secondly, participant observation obliges the fieldworker to take into account all aspects of a particular community of people.
Tedlock, b from participant observation to the observation of participation. Skill and commitment participant observation requires agreat deal of skill and commitment from the researcher. Participant observation in social research revisesociology. Participant observation educational research basics by del. Ethnography cambridge encyclopedia of anthropology. Learn participant observation with free interactive flashcards. It is a complex blend of methods and techniques of observation, informant interviewing, respondent interviewing, and document analysis. This method, called participant observation, while necessary and useful for gaining a thorough understanding of a foreign culture, is in practice quite difficult. Mar 31, 2016 participant observation is where the researcher joins in with the group being studied and observes their behaviour. This post covers the theoretical, practical and ethical strengths and limitations of using overt and covert participant observation in social research. The observation of participation and the emergence of public ethnography barbara tedlock p articipant observation was created during the late 19th century as an ethnographic field method for the study of small, homogeneous cultures. Participant observation and experiences in the design for.
Participant observation a participantobserver investigating high school student iife. Participant observation begins with widefocused descriptive observations. Geography and anthropology share a traditional commitment to fieldwork and firsthand observation which has been relatively neglected in recent years. Covert participant observation sociology factsheet uk 9. From participant observation to the observation of. Participant observation as a data collection method. In the observation of participation, ethnographers both experience and observe their. This text is a followup to his ethnographic research handbook, the ethnographic interview, and guides readers through the technique of participant observation to research ethnography and culture. The history of participant observation as a method participant observation is considered a staple in anthropological studies, especially in ethnographic studies, and has been used as a data collection method for over a century. The privileging of participant observation as a scientific method encouraged.
In handbook of qualitative research, 2nd edition, ed. Just as the anthropologist brings to the situation certain inherent, if unconscious, cultural biases, so also is he influenced by the. From participant observation to observant participation. Fieldwork, anthropology, organizational ethnography, observant. Jan 29, 2016 participant observation to research education a brief summary of young, gifted and black 1988 by mairtin mac an ghaill and a consideration of the practical, ethical and theoretical advantages and disadvantages of the method in this educational context. This text is a follow up to spradleys earlier ethographic research mostcommoninterviewquestions. As a participant, the researcher attempts to get as close as possible to the group that he or she is studying to best understand it. Nov 28, 2008 participant observation michael, anna, stacey, laurisa, april slideshare uses cookies to improve functionality and performance, and to provide you with relevant advertising. Ethnography syllabus 09 university of massachusetts amherst. Meanwhile, overt participant observation in a field of enquiry where the researcher clearly states their reasons for involvement in the field and their research aims will, of course, alert participants to the possibilities that their conduct is being watched. More accurately, this transformation is one that sees the formers focus upon the. Unstructured observations are recorded as field notes, audio or video, transcribed verbatim then analysed. As such, the method directs the anthropologist to study that which is of significance to the community studied rather than test a number of hypotheses formulated in advance of the fieldwork.
Tedlock, barbara 1991 from participant observation to the observation of. Feb 17, 2016 spradley should be read by anyone who wants to gain a true understanding of the process of participant observation. Pdf from participant observation to observant participation. Qualitative descriptions generated by participant observation are used to formulate. Some authors are more pessimistic in arguing that participantobservation is an. Pdf participant observation as a data collection method. Observation, particularly participant observation, has been used in a variety of disciplines as a tool for collecting data about people, processes, and cultures in qualitative research. In her brief historical sketch of ethnography, tedlock 2000 explains that ethnography began. She is the author of the beautiful and the dangerous. The success or failure of the research will hinge on such factors as the ability to fitin with the people being studied. This paper reports on our experience as participant observers in a project. Ethnography leads to the creation of narratives stories that are embedded in multiple contexts e.
178 49 592 821 1302 704 56 304 1143 1146 1284 67 1048 1387 1458 97 1332 1303 750 686 865 751 1179 683 822 179 807 838 1321 271 465 506 1310 364 1243